top 3 reasons to stay with us


The tranquility of a PRIVATE ISLAND within Christiansted. Convenient to shopping, restaurants, bistros, historical attractions & nightlight



Cruciann culture is deeply rooted in the history of the islands. It reflects the wide array of different cultures who have called St. Croix home that have melded and transformed into what we know as St. Croix culture today.Reservations


Hotel on the Cay is tranquility at its finest. Unwind and relax with ocean waves, a quiet atmosphere and beautiful caribbean furnishings.Reservations






Hotel on the Cay, located on a lush, five acre cay (pronounced key) has a long history of intrigue dating back to the 17th century when pirates anchored their ships off the beach where guests now sunbathe, swim and snorkel. Our property (many believe was the inspiration for Herman Wouk’s famous book Don’t Stop the Carnival) is a combination hotel and time-share located on Protestant Cay, a 2 minute ferry ride from downtown Christiansted.